Justice Joan Orie Melvin’s preliminary hearing ended yesterday.  According to an article in the Pittsburgh Post Gazette, she will stand trial for 7 counts: “three counts of theft of services and one count of conspiracy to commit theft of services — all felonies — as well as on one count each of misapplication of government property, official oppression and conspiracy to tamper with evidence — all misdemeanors.” Magisterial District Judge James J. Hanley Jr. dismissed two counts: one count of criminal solicitation and one count of official oppression.  Both counts were misdemeanors. 
 
The official oppression charge was dismissed because “mistreatment” was required; the witness, Molly Creenan, Orie Melvin’s former law clerk, testified to feeling “stressed.” Jamie Pavlot, Orie Melvin’s former chief of staff testified regarding the criminal solicitation charge.  Judge James J. Hanley Jr., found her testimony to be “confused.”
 
Justice Orie Melvin has pleaded not guilty to all charges.  Her arraignment is scheduled for August 14, 2012.  According to an article in the Pittsburgh Tribune Review, on August 14, 2012 she will also go before the “Court of Judicial Discipline in Harrisburg, which will determine whether she will continue to receive her $195,309 salary.”  Justice Orie Melvin’s trial date has not been set.