Intermediate Appellate Courts

Appellate judges are elected for ten year terms, which begin the January following the election and end in January ten years later. If an appellate judge wishes to run for retention for another ten year term, the retention election would be held in the November preceding the expiration of the judge's term.  Appellate judges must retire at the end of the year in which they reach age 70.

According to the Pennsylvania Manual, "senior judges are ... both retired and former judges who, with their consent, are assigned to temporary judicial service by the Surpreme Court of Pennsylvania."  All judges seeking assignment must have served at least 10 years and not have been defeated for reelection or retention, or, in the case of judges who retired mandatorily at age 70, must have served at least five years.  Senior judges may serve until the last day of the year in which they reach the age of 78; however, judges appointed to senior status prior to the 2002 amendment to Rule 701 may serve until the end of the year inwhich they reach the age of 80.

The tables below identify the current appellate judges, when their terms expire, when they will be eligible to stand for retention, and when they will be subject to mandatory retirement.  Notations of "not eligible" mean that the justice cannot stand for retention, either because he or she will reach the mandatory retirement age before his or her next retention election would occur or because the justice was appointed to an interim vacancy and is elibile to serve only until the next regularly occurring election. The justices are listed in the order by which future vacancies will occur.

 

Superior Court Judges (15)
Name Next Election Retention Reaches Mandatory Retirement Age Year of Election to Fill Vacancy County Gender Race

Richard B. Klein

 

Not eligible 2009 2009 Philadelphia M C
John Cleland Not eligible   2009 McKean M C
Richard Freedberg Not eligible   2009 Northampton M C

John L. Musmanno

Not eligible 2012 2013 Allegheny M C
Correale F. Stevens Not eligible 2016 2017 Luzerne M C
John T. Bender Nov. 2011 2018 2019 Allegheny M C
Maureen Lally-Green Nov. 2009 2019 2019 Butler F C
Kate Ford Elliott (PJ*) Nov. 2009 2019 2019 Allegheny F C
Susan Gantman Nov. 2013 2022 2023 Montgomery F C
Mary Jane Bowes Nov. 2011 2024 2025 Allegheny F C
Jack Panella Nov. 2013 2025 2025 Northampton M C
Joan Orie Melvin Nov. 2017 2026 2027 Allegheny F C
Cheryl Allen Not eligible 2017 2017 Allegheny F AA
Christine Donohue Nov. 2017 2022 2023 Allegheny F C
Jacqueline Shogun Nov. 2017 2023 2023 Westmoreland F C
          7M/8F 1 minority 

 

KEY: "County" indicates the individual's resident county at the time he/she was initially commissioned to the current office. "CJ" or "PJ" next to a name indicates a Chief Justice or President Judge, respectively. In the "Race" column, "C" denotes Caucasian, and "AA" denotes African American.

COMMONWEALTH COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA

The judges are listed in the order by which a future vacancy would occur.

 

Commonwealth Court Judges (9)
Name Next Election Retention Reaches Mandatory Retirement Age Year of Election to Fill Vacancy County Gender Race
Rochelle S. Friedman Not eligible 2008 2009 Allegheny F C
Johnny J. Butler Not eligible   2009 Philadelphia M AA
Dante Robert Pellegrini Nov. 2009 2015 2015 Allegheny M C
Doris A. Smith-Ribner Not eligible 2015 2015 Allegheny F AA
Bernard L. McGinley, II Not eligible 2016 2017 Allegheny M C
Mary Hannah Leavitt Nov. 2011 2017 2017 Dauphin F C
Bonnie B. Leadbetter (PJ)* Not eligible 2017 2017 Montgomery F C
Robert E. Simpson, Jr. Nov. 2011 2021 2021 Northampton M C
Renee L. Cohn Jubelirer Nov. 2011 2027 2027 Lehigh F C
          5M/5F 2 minority

 

KEY: "County" indicates the individual's resident county at the time he/she was initially commissioned to the current office. "CJ" or "PJ" next to a name indicates a Chief Justice or President Judge, respectively. In the "Race" column, "C" denotes Caucasian, and "AA" denotes African American.